The Myth of the ‘Promised Land’: Rethinking Sacred Spaces in a Divinely Crafted World

The Myth of the ‘Promised Land’: Rethinking Sacred Spaces in a Divinely Crafted World November 13, 2023

Photo by Sandi Benedicta on Unsplash

In the labyrinth of religious narratives, the idea of a Promised Land stands out as a curious paradox, especially when you throw in the all-encompassing nature of a God who supposedly created everything under the sun, stars, and beyond. If the entire universe is a divine creation, singling out a specific plot as holier-than-thou seems like a celestial game of Monopoly, doesn’t it?

The Biblical ‘Promised Land’: A Divine Real Estate Deal?

Let’s start at the beginning – or at least the book of Genesis. The Promised Land is a significant motif in the Biblical narrative, particularly for the Israelites. It’s portrayed as a divine pledge, a specific parcel of land reserved for God’s chosen people. This land, famously described as flowing with “milk and honey,” represents an idealized utopia brimming with abundance and prosperity. But here’s the catch: if God created the entire cosmos, singling out a specific GPS coordinate as the Promised Land raises questions. Is God playing favorites, or is it a divine marketing strategy to keep the believers in line? Humans give significance to places and spaces typically because something happened there. This Holy Ground or Sacred Space is about enshrining a past event as special or true. But isn’t it curious how these places are always about the past, never the present?

Context is King: Historical and Cultural Lens

Historically, the Promised Land concept might have been a beacon of hope for a nomadic tribe seeking a permanent postal address. It’s a powerful symbol – a divine assurance of stability and prosperity. However, if we think about it, what’s intriguing is how these spaces gain their sacredness over time, as more people buy into the idea. It’s a bit like history being written by the victors – get enough people to agree, and any place can become promised or sacred.

The Modern Twist: Relevance in Today’s World

Fast forward to the present, and the Promised Land idea is still floating around, often hijacked by political agendas. It’s like a theological trump card used to justify territorial claims or to paint a narrative of us vs. them. But isn’t this just living in the shadows of historical narratives instead of walking our own path into new experiences? The imagery of a land of milk and honey tantalizes with its promise of a perfect world, yet often overshadows the sanctity of the land beneath our feet.

Philosophical Ponderings: Ethical Dilemmas of the Divine Dibs

Philosophically speaking, the idea of a Promised Land in a divinely crafted world is a puzzler. It’s akin to saying, “All of God’s creation is sacred, but this little piece right here? Extra sacred.” Are we merely passengers in life, seeking significance through the lives of those gone before us, rather than forging our own paths?

St. Francis of Assisi understood this when he prayed, “Lord, make me an instrument of your peace,” emphasizing action and presence in the world rather than passive reverence of the past. This notion of actively engaging with the world as it is, rather than as it was, is a powerful counterpoint to the idea of a static, historical Promised Land.

The Global and Environmental Angle: One Earth, Many ‘Promised Lands’

From an environmental perspective, treating one part of the planet as more sacred than another is like saying only some parts of the sky deserve stars. In a world grappling with climate change and ecological crises, perhaps it’s time to see every inch of the planet as promised and worthy of our stewardship. Sacredness and holiness are all around us if we choose to see them.

A Personal Reflection: Land, Land Everywhere, Not a Spot to Privatize

In my own journey through the corridors of faith, I’ve come to see the idea of a Promised Land as a bit of a theological misstep. All of creation should be revered and cared for. To elevate one region over another reeks of a divine power play, sowing seeds of division. Sacredness isn’t about places; it’s about moments and experiences. I’ve found deep solace in both centuries-old cathedrals and tattoo parlors. To see spaces as holy or not leads us to miss the point that life, in all its forms and places, is sacred and happening.

As Madeleine L’Engle once reflected, gazing at the galaxies and the brilliance of creation enlarges us, connecting us to the vastness of the universe. This sense of awe and wonder is not confined to traditional holy spaces but is present in all creation.

In conclusion, maybe it’s time we ditch the old notion of a singular Promised Land and start seeing every inch of this planet as a sacred space, a part of the divine tapestry. After all, in a world created by an all-encompassing God, shouldn’t every grain of sand, every leaf, every drop of water be a piece of that promise? The land of milk and honey may be a poetic ideal, but the true sacredness lies in recognizing the divinity in every corner of our world, in living our lives and stories right here, right now.

About Stuart Delony
My hope with Snarky Faith is to incite change no matter how big or small. I want to cultivate conversations that help people to look for new ways to live out their faith. I'm also one of the weird ones who think that God still moves today - we're just looking in the wrong places. You can read more about the author here.

Browse Our Archives